top of page

Feeling Stuck in Medicare Advantage? Overcoming Barriers to Transition to Original Medicare

Navigating the intricacies of healthcare can often feel like traversing a maze blindfolded. And for many seniors, this labyrinthine journey leads them to Medicare Advantage plans. While these plans offer a promising alternative to Original Medicare, some beneficiaries find themselves feeling stuck in a complex web of coverage options, costs, and limitations. If you're among those feeling bewildered by your Medicare Advantage plan, fear not. Here's what you need to know to untangle yourself from the confusion.

Understanding Medicare Advantage:

Medicare Advantage, also known as Medicare Part C, is an alternative to traditional Medicare. These plans are offered by private insurance companies approved by Medicare and must cover all the services that Original Medicare does (except hospice care, which remains covered under Part A). Many Advantage plans also include additional benefits such as vision, dental, and prescription drug coverage.

Medicare Advantage as a Choice: One of the primary draws of Medicare Advantage plans is their potential for cost savings and added benefits. Premiums for these plans can be lower than those for supplemental insurance with Original Medicare, and they often include coverage for services not covered by traditional Medicare, like dental and vision care. Moreover, Medicare Advantage plans frequently come bundled with prescription drug coverage, eliminating the need for a separate Part D plan.

When Medicare Advantage is Not an Advantage Despite their advantages, some beneficiaries find themselves disappointed with their choice and within the confines of their Medicare Advantage plans. Common sources of disappointment include limited provider networks, prior authorization requirements, unexpected out-of-pocket costs and significant risk of cost sharing when you need hospital or rehabilitative care. Additionally, annual changes to plan benefits, formularies, and provider networks can leave enrollees feeling uncertain about their coverage from year to year. 

Stuck in Medicare Advantage

Medicare Advantage

If you're dissatisfied with your current plan, you have the option to switch during the annual Medicare Open Enrollment Period (October 15 to December 7). Use this time to compare plans based on cost, coverage, and provider networks to find one that better suits your needs. While there is a second enrollment period after the beginning of a new year, this annual Medicare Open Enrollment is the only time you can move from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare.

However, unless you live in one of the few states that allow you to move from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare without medical underwriting, you will feel stuck and not able to move to Original Medicare in that you will not medically qualify for a Medigap or supplemental insurance plan that is a necessary coverage for those who enroll in Original Medicare. 

Addressing Preexisting Conditions: 

  1. Know Your Rights: Federal and state laws provide certain protections for Medigap enrollees, including guaranteed issue rights in specific circumstances.

  2. Leverage Special Enrollment Periods: Life events, such as loss of coverage or relocation, can trigger special enrollment periods with guaranteed issue rights for Medigap policies.

  3. Explore State-Specific Protections: Some states offer additional consumer protections, such as extended guaranteed issue rights or limitations on medical underwriting. Unfortunately, Pennsylvania is NOT one of those states.

  4. Seek Assistance: PA MEDI – Medicare counseling is the free and confidential counseling. It is a statewide program and provides free, unbiased personalized help with all things Medicare.  Another source of assistance is licensed insurance agents specializing in Medicare. But, many of these agents may focus on Medicare Advantage.

  5. Current Insurance Provider: Consulting with your current provider can uncover additional options for securing coverage. Perhaps there is an option to convert without a preexisting condition or other specific coverage options that require an analysis of your coverage and your condition.

Transitioning from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare with preexisting conditions requires careful consideration and strategic planning. By understanding your rights, exploring special enrollment periods, researching state-specific protections, seeking assistance, and checking with your current insurance provider for additional relief options, you can navigate this process with greater confidence and clarity.

Don't let confusion or frustration keep you trapped—take charge of your healthcare journey and explore the possibilities that lie ahead.

Schedule a Call

9 views0 comments


bottom of page